From Pantry Staple to Portfolio Risk 📉

J.M. Smucker $SJM just reminded investors that not even iconic consumer brands are immune to execution risk.

The $10B packaged food giant reported mixed results on Tuesday and suffered the worst earnings reaction in company history.

And it wasn’t just the headline numbers.

The company revised its long-term growth expectations lower for its recently acquired Sweet Baked Snacks portfolio.

They also lowered forward EPS guidance below consensus expectations.

These aren’t isolated issues. 

They reflect broader challenges of a flawed growth strategy.

For decades, this was a defensive compounder, anchored by brands like Jif, Folgers, Uncrustables, and Smucker’s jam. 

But its recent shift into new categories, primarily through the Hostess acquisition, hasn’t gone as smoothly as hoped.

Margins are under pressure, and inventory costs are increasing.

The market’s verdict? It’s an apparent loss of confidence.

So what else did we learn from this earnings report? Let’s dive into the details.

Here are the latest earnings stats for SJM 👇

*Click the image to enlarge it

J.M. Smucker had a -9.87 reaction score after reporting mixed results.

The company reported revenues of $2.14B, versus the expected $2.18B, and earnings per share of $2.31, versus the expected $2.24. 

Now let's dive into the data and talk about what happened with this report 👇

SJM had its worst earnings reaction ever:

J.M. Smucker fell 15.6% after this earnings report, and here's why:

• Free cash flow for fiscal 2025 came in about $100M short of prior guidance ($817M vs. $925M) due to inventory inflation.
• Long-term growth expectations for the Sweet Baked Snacks portfolio were revised downward from 4% to 3%
• The management team also lowered its adjusted EPS forward guidance below the consensus expectation.

This was the worst earnings reaction in the company's history, and the chart reflects why.

The stock has spent over a decade forming a massive distribution pattern. 

The lower boundary of that range has now failed to hold as support.

Unless the stock can reclaim that breakdown, the path of least resistance is shifting from sideways to lower.

This setup has all the hallmarks of a long-term trend reversal. 

If SJM is below 99, the path of least resistance is lower for the foreseeable future.

Thank you for reading.

- The Beat Report Team 

P.S.: Jeff Macke has seen it all — from inside the hedge fund world to behind the CNBC anchor desk. In his Retail Report, he brings you his latest trades, sector commentary, and sharp takes on the companies that move shelves and stocks. Follow along here — no cost.

If you find our content valuable, we would greatly appreciate it if you could share it with your friends, family, and colleagues. Your help in spreading the word is invaluable in supporting our work. Thank you to all of you who share!